The Bakery At The Amish Door

The Bakery At The Amish Door

The Bakery At The Amish Door

The Bakery At The Amish Door

The Amish Door Bakery

Welcome to The Amish Door Bakery, where we specialize in creating homemade donuts, creamsticks, and our famous apple fritters! We take pride in using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients, sourced locally whenever possible, to ensure every bite is deliciously memorable.

Our donuts are a customer favorite, crafted daily to guarantee the perfect blend of fluffy and sweet. The creamsticks are irresistibly creamy, and our apple fritters have earned a reputation for being simply AWESOME — a must-try for any visitor!

While we are known for our donuts, creamsticks and apple fritters, we also offer a delightful selection of homemade pies. Our pies feature flaky, buttery crusts and are filled with rich, flavorful fillings. From classic apple to indulgent cherry and seasonal pumpkin, each pie is crafted to capture the essence of homemade goodness.

At The Amish Door Bakery, we believe the best treats are made with care and precision. That’s why everything we serve is made by hand, from mixing the dough to glazing the creamsticks.

Whether you’re treating yourself or searching for the perfect gift, our bakery has something to delight everyone. Stop by today to indulge in our top-selling donuts, creamsticks, or the crowd-pleasing apple fritters!

Brown Bag Apple (Premium)
Cherry (Premium)
Pecan (Premium)
Red Raspberry (Premium)
Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Dutch Apple
Peanut Butter Cream
Red Raspberry Cream
Apple (no sugar added)
Cherry (no sugar added)

Grape Cream
Pumpkin Custard
Sugar-free Pumpkin
Rhubarb Crumb

Butterscotch Coffee Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Buttermilk Cookies
Raspberry Shortbread Thumbprint Cookies
Cookie Trays (assorted)
…much more!

In-store availability varies.
For large or special orders, call us at (330) 359-5464 x404

Cake Donuts
Iced Donuts
Glazed Donuts
Cream Sticks
Apple Fritters
Fry Pies
Jelly-filled Donuts
Cinnamon Rolls
Whoopie Pies
Seasonal Donuts
…much more!

In-store availability varies.

For large or special orders, call us at (330) 359-5464 x404

White Bread
Wheat Bread
Dinner Rolls
Cheese Bread
Cinnamon Swirl Bread
…much more!

In-store availability varies.

For large or special orders, call us at (330) 359-5464 x404

Chocolate Walnut
Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Chocolate
Tiger Butter
Coconut Cream
Raspberry Vanilla Cream
Cookies and Cream
Birthday Cake

Dine With Us

Stay With Us

Shop With Us

There are a lot of community events booked at our premises.
Come and enjoy the local gatherings with us.

Our customers speak for themselves

And so does our track record. Our 45+ years of service preceeds Google Reviews for many decades, but even in the short span of the internet reviews' existence, we have amassed an impressive 2.907 reviews just on Google, the vast majority of them being 5 Stars. 

OMG this was an awesome experience! I got the "Taste of Amish Country" and it was delicious! The salad bar is huge, and is as equally amazing! My server was amazing as well! I would recommend to anyone to come and try them out!


Love Amish food like forever. I am a vegetarian and my husband a non-vegetarian and we both enjoyed our food, it's all about simple freshness and it's like coming back to warm food and comfort. Love it here.


Our food and service were amazing. It brings back so many wonderful memories of time spent with my grandparents!


This was our first time here, but not the last. Every single thing was so good and fresh. Customer service was top notch and the store was nicely maintained, inside and out.


The food at salad bar was really good and plenty of it. Also so very clean and well organized. Well worth the trip.


Weddings at the Amish Door

Create a unique experience for your most important moments
in our Amish Door wedding venue.


Directions to the Amish Door

From Columbus

An easy drive two hours north on 71, east on US 30 and continuing east on US 250. When you get to Wilmot, follow the signs in!

From Cleveland

Take 77 South until you pick up 21 South and OH 93 South. Follow US 62 West and watch for the signs to lead you the rest of the way.

From Akron/Canton

Follow 77 South to US 250 West until you get to Wilmot. It's that easy.

From Cambridge / 77 South

Hop on 77 North, then take US 250 West until you find Wilmot. An hour and change.

From Wheeling

Follow the signs to stay on US 250 West until you pick up 77 North. Exit at US 250 West and keep cruising to Wilmot.

From Pittsburgh

Take US 22 West for about an hour, then continue west on US 250 and keep on as it merges with US 800 North. Take 77 North and head west on US 250.

Join Our eNewsletter

Sign up today for specials, coupons, live event announcements, and the latest updates on what’s happening at the Amish Door Village!

Subscribe our newsletter